If you’re looking for a place to treat someone special to a fantastic dinner in the West Islip, New York, area, you’re in luck. There are plenty of restaurants that offer luxurious and romantic atmospheres and plenty of great food for those who want a night to remember. Here are a few of our favorites. 
Tellers
For a fantastic and romantic steakhouse dinner, reserve a table at Tellers. The expertly crafted cuisine at Tellers is just the beginning of the experience. The ambiance of their dining hall and patio area make for one of the most romantic you’ll find in the area. And their selection is to be taken seriously: chophouses classics galore, local oysters, Maine lobsters, and more line the dinner menu. Whether you’re celebrating your anniversary or making the night you’ll celebrate next year, Tellers is a quality choice.
Da Noi Italian Restaurant
Nothing is more romantic than a classic Italian dinner at a table for two. If this sounds like what you’re looking for, head to Da Noi Italian Restaurant. Ask your server for the perfect wine pairing to go with your favorite Mediterranean dish. Start your experience with an antipasto of calamari fritti or burrata before moving on to veal bolognese, vegetable primavera, or any of the other authentic Italian dishes on their menu. Da Noi specializes in creating memorable dining experiences.
Verace
For a more modern Italian experience in a chic setting, try Verace. They have indoor seating centered around an exposed woodstone oven as well as a picturesque outdoor patio dining area that’s perfect for setting the scene of your night. As far as food options, you can’t go wrong with their 21-day dry-aged steak or a wood-fired classic pizza to share.
The Lakehouse
The Lakehouse is a beautiful restaurant overlooking the Great South Bay, and it is the perfect place to surprise your someone special. Their dining areas look like the stuff movies are made of, and their food is just as thoughtfully crafted. Order a charcuterie board to pair with your wines for a delectable sensory experience. The Lakehouse’s curated entree list includes chef-inspired dishes such as pepper-crusted New Zealand venison, organic herb-roasted chicken, and caramelized local sea scallops.
AJI 53
If you both love Asian cuisine, AJI 53 is where you need to be. Their modern spin on classic Japanese food looks as good as it tastes. Whether you split a few sushi rolls or try one of their authentic Japanese entrees, you’re sure to find a great dinner at this chic restaurant. AJI 53’s atmosphere transports you away from New York to a well-designed Japanese favorite. With reasonable prices to boot, AJI 53 is one of our favorite places to dine when we’re celebrating.
No matter your tastes in food, you’re sure to find a romantic night on the town at any of these or the many other great restaurants in West Islip. Treat your someone special to a night they won’t forget, for which a great meal is a requirement.
Connect with us
