The West Islip area is known for its numerous restaurants ranging from Mexican to Italian to good old American classics. Whether you live in the West Islip area or expect to be passing through, be sure to stop by one of the area’s best restaurants listed below to try some American comfort classics.
The Lake House
If you’re looking for some amazing views while you dine as well as world-class service, look no further than The Lake House. This upscale restaurant offers beautifully plated American cuisine with an emphasis on fresh seafood dishes. You can choose from lunch, dinner, or brunch, and the restaurant is the perfect place to host a special occasion or enjoy a quiet date night. While you can’t go wrong with any of the menu choices, some of the must-try options include the caramelized local sea scallops, the crispy suckling pig, or Long Island duck breasts with crispy leg confit.
Tula Kitchen
Sanskrit for “balance,” Tula is a word the chef at Tula’s Kitchen keeps in mind every time she creates a dish. The chef prides herself on providing clean, delicious, nutritious, and tasty cuisine to enjoy with family. Menu items include all organic vegetarian proteins, and items are baked rather than fried. Most menu options are gluten-free, and the restaurant also offers numerous vegetarian and vegan options. Located in the downtown area, the restaurant is known for its ambiance, French decor, and a handcrafted old world bar. When stopping by, be sure to try the Tula burrito, the baked salmon cakes, or the po-kay bowl.
Peter Pan Diner and Restaurant
A landmark in the Long Island community for over 40 years, Peter Pan Diner and Restaurant has attracted visitors all the way from the west coast. Visitors come not only for the classic American cuisine but also for the friendly, down-to-earth service and a special welcome from one of the owners. Peter Pan Diner prides themselves on providing their customers with good food, good people, and great memories. Most days you will find multiple regulars in their favorites spots. You can choose from the breakfast, lunch, and dinner menus, and some of the favorite items popular with locals include the Western omelet, Texas smoke sandwich, and Tuscany Panini.
Captain Bill’s and the Bayview House
Known as one of the premier waterfront restaurants in Long Island, Captain Bill’s is located on the south shore of the island at the Bay Shore Marina. You can enjoy beautiful views of the harbor while you dine, and sunsets are always a popular time for guests. The upscale dining and decor make it the perfect place to enjoy a romantic date night or a special dinner with the family. The restaurant is open for lunch and dinner as well as Sundays for brunch. Menu offerings include seafood dishes, aged steaks, and an extensive wine list. Make sure to try the broiled seafood platter, grilled filet mignon, or the grilled Atlantic salmon.
Tantalize your palate by stopping by one of these four West Islip area restaurants to enjoy some unforgettable American dining.
“Aunt Yoke Ling’s Grilled Prawns” via Flickr by avlxyz. Used with permission via CC BY-SA 2.0 / cropped from original.
Connect with us
